Comment on this article |
View comments |
Email this Article
|
News :: Civil & Human Rights : Health |
Psychiatric Abuse of a Client at the Mental Health Center of Champaign County |
Current rating: 0 |
by Abused Client (No verified email address) |
08 Apr 2005
Modified: 08:25:15 AM |
A psychiatrist at the Mental Health Center of Champaign County (MHCCC) subjects a client to psychological abuse, forcing the client to terminate his services. MHCCC refuses to allow reassignment of the client's case to another psychiatrist and fails to respond to the client's grievances in an effective matter. This client is currently without access to psychiatric services. |
Last fall, I was forced to fire my psychiatrist at the Mental Health
Center of Champaign County (MHCCC) because he subjected me to psychological
abuse. During some of our meetings, he made statements like "Your life is a
waste" and "I don't care if you commit suicide." Whenever anything went wrong
in my life for whatever reason, he always placed the blame on me. During our
last meeting, this psychiatrist falsely accused me of blackmailing him (as if I
could do this) and threatened to call the police if I displayed any symptoms of
emotional instability in his office. This psychiatrist stated that he would not
admit me into a psychiatric facility even if I was feeling suicidal at the
time. Because of his intolerable behavior, I fired this psychiatrist and told
him that I was unwilling to see him again, to which he responded: "That is your
right."
When I attempted to set up an appointment with a second
psychiatrist at MHCCC, I was told by the receptionist and a psychiatric nurse
that I could not do this, unless: 1) my old psychiatrist agreed with this
decision, and 2) the new psychiatrist agreed with this decision. However,
contrary to his earlier statement, my old psychiatrist would not allow my case
to be transferred to another psychiatrist. As a result, I was not allowed to
see any psychiatrist at MHCCC except the one who had subjected me to
psychological abuse. Not only did this psychiatrist subject me to psychological
abuse, he also indicated his willingness to criminalize my mental illness and
to engage in medical malpractice by not admitting me to a psychiatric facility
even when I was in danger of killing myself. Under Illinois law, it is a felony
if a medical practitioner refuses to admit a suicidal person into a medical
facility for treatment.
To make matters even worse, I am not able to
make an appointment with a psychiatrist at another organization in
Champaign-Urbana because they don't accept reimbursements from Medicaid and I
can't afford to pay what they normally charge for their services. Fortunately,
my family physician accepts Medicaid and was willing to write prescriptions for
my psychiatric medication. Thus, I remain on psychiatric medications because of
my family physician, while the Mental Health Center of Champaign County (MHCCC)
has abandoned me to the high winds. I imagine that there are many other clients
who have experienced similar problems with the psychiatrists and policies of
MHCCC.
I filed a grievance against the abusive psychiatrist with the
client ombudsman at MHCCC. She acknowledged my complaint and discussed my
grievance with this psychiatrist. However, to my knowledge, this psychiatrist
has not been sanctioned or punished for his behavior in any way. On one
occasion, this psychiatrist even bragged to me that my grievance would not
change anything and he would add it to the "rest of the complaints" that have
been directed against him by other clients. I also filed a grievance against
the policy at MHCCC that a client can't change psychiatrists without first
receiving permission for the transfer from both the old and new psychiatrists.
However, the client ombudsman indicated to me that the psychiatrists at MHCCC
were of "like mind" on this issue and they refused to change the transfer
policy. The client ombudsman stated that she would bring my grievance to the
attention of the Clinical Review Team at MHCCC, but apparently the Clinical
Review Team did nothing to change this policy as it remains in
force.
|
This work is in the public domain |
Comments
Re: Psychiatric Abuse of a Client at the Mental Health Center of Champaign County |
by uh-nawn (No verified email address) |
Current rating: 0 08 Apr 2005
|
This is only your side of the story. Perhaps your refusal to admit that most of the problems in your life are your own fault, is the reason that the shrink you "fired" was tired of providing you counseling that was clearly of no benefit.
Just because you're crazy and see everyone else as the problem, doesn't mean anybody owes you perpetual forgiveness and understanding. Let alone a doctor being paid for by Medicaid, that most likely sincerely tried to help you before you made him/her the enemy.
In the meantime, you're probably well served to keep taking your pills. |
Re: Psychiatric Abuse of a Client at the Mental Health Center of Champaign County |
by Abused Client (No verified email address) |
Current rating: 0 08 Apr 2005
|
I have not presented only my side of the story, but have stated the plain and simple facts -- otherwise I would not have bothered to post this article as my time is too valuable to be wasted on anything else.
un-nawn states: "Perhaps your refusal to admit that most of the problems in your life ARE your own fault, is the reason that the shrink you 'fired' was tired of providing you counseling that was clearly of no benefiti."
Oh, I see . . . . If a client with major mental illness fails to get better after a shrink provides a little "counseling," then its the client's fault if he or she fails to improve . . . . That's an interesting little theory, uh-nawn, except that a multitude of scientific studies have revealed that genetic factors play an important role in the development of major mental illness. Because a person with major mental illness has no control over the genome that they've been born with, it becomes nonsensical to blame him or her for whatever problems they encounter as a result of being mentally ill. Your comment is a fine example of "blaming the victim," and it reveals the chronic hostility that many members of the middle class direct towards persons with major mental illness.
uh-nawn states: "Just because you're crazy and see everyone else as the problem . . ."
I am not crazy and do not see everyone else as the problem. However, I DO think that we live in a society that is excessively violent and aggressive, and as a result of this people with sensitive nerves become stressed out in the process (and there are millions of us).
Unfortunately, the mental health system is badly broken and provides very little benefit to the clients that it is supposed to be serviing. As a matter of fact, the mental health professionals who like to think that they are "helping" their clients, more often than not are making their mental illness much worse by subjecting them to a regimen of mental cruelty. The problems that I encountered with this psychiatrist is just the tip of the iceberg.
un-nawn states: "In the meantime, you're probably well served to keep taking your pills."
There're certainly more effective than the 'counseling' of that damn psychiatrist . . . . |
Re: Psychiatric Abuse of a Client at the Mental Health Center of Champaign County |
by 5 (No verified email address) |
Current rating: 0 09 Apr 2005
|
I have to say that your comments are rather bizarre, uh-nawn.
How the heck would you know if Abused Client accepts responsibility for his problems? You don't. AC is talking about mistreatment while attempting to seek treatment.
To call someone crazy is to show absolute ignorance of mental illness.
Your stance seems to be that if you are poor and have problems with your mental health care provider, tough noogies. As someone who has received counseling, there are many different disciplines and philosphies in mental health. If I got a whack-job Freud-worshipping counselor when seeking treatment for sexual abuse, you bet your bippy I'd be looking for a new counselor. Or, let's say that I was a gay person who suffered from depression.... Should I be forced to see a psychologist who still subscribes to the theory that homosexuality is a mental illness just because I am poor?
The point is that if there is no trust or rapport between the practitioner and the patient, it is in the client's and practitioner's best interests to find a more suitable situation.
What we have here is an individual who has sought help who is now getting none. Simply taking medicine fixes nothing. If you have a torn ligament in your knee, taking Ibuprofen may make you feel better, but it fixes nothing. |
Re: Psychiatric Abuse of a Client at the Mental Health Center of Champaign County |
by beholder (No verified email address) |
Current rating: 0 10 Apr 2005
|
I fully agree with 5, uh-nawn, as to tell psychiatric patient that it doesn't bother him/her whether this client is going to commit suicide or not for any doctor is the same as to refuse to try to cure a client, which is the obvious breach of Hippocratic oath, which all doctors should follow in their professional actions. Actually, this psychiatrist should be fired, I think, or heavily punished. He/she can't work with his/her clientele, if he/she is allowing himself/herself statements like that.
What kind of relevance does this article have to Israel , etc., 'dahhhhhhh'? I honestly don't see ANY at all. |
Re: Psychiatric Abuse of a Client at the Mental Health Center of Champaign County |
by sympathetic (No verified email address) |
Current rating: 0 12 Apr 2005
|
I think uh-nawn is about as helpful as putting salt in an open wound. No compassion or understanding! I think uh-nawn should be censored and/or be held responsible for his/her actions. What a joke! people on this website sympathize with any stranger-- from any country --- but have no compassion for our own neighbors.... Now it is understandable why we have so many problems in our community with very few viable solutions. |
And Who Exactly Are You Referring To? |
by regular reader (No verified email address) |
Current rating: 0 12 Apr 2005
|
sympathetic wrote:
"people on this website sympathize with any stranger-- from any country"
OK, that's true enough. There's no compassion deficit in this crowd.
sympathetic followed with:
"but have no compassion for our own neighbors...."
And who exactly are you referiing to with that statement, sympathetic?
The occassional troll?
Because the occassional troll does not do things like organize Books to Prisoners, nor do they have a monthly paper, the Public i, that anyone can get published in, nor have they organized a new community radio station, WRFU, that anyone can join and put there own kind of programming out over the public's airwaves, nor would they be involved in projects like Food not Bombs or the Community Wireless Project. And trolls certainly wouldn't bother with fighting for reforms at the County Jail or a Living Wage,which have involved IMC members working as hard on those projects as they do on making the IMC the great community resource that it is.
No, trolls would not do any of those things, but those are the kind of people who are IMC members. The IMC offers a place for them and the community, people like Abused Client for instance, to tell their own stories, write their own articles, and discuss their own point of view.
The occasional troll drops by, like they did here, and guess what happens? Some other troll (or maybe the same one) makes some smart-ass statement that implies that people here are hypocrites -- when it's pretty obvious that such a conclusion is easily refutable with a few facts -- and the whole thing sounds eerily just like the stunt Disappointed pulled in this recent thread:
http://www.ucimc.org/newswire/display/31253/index.php
It's kind of odd how one troll here tends to sound just like another. I think the gang is onto something when they decide that this is really no coincidence.
Good luck, sympathetic, you're pathetic. |
Re: Psychiatric Abuse of a Client at the Mental Health Center of Champaign County |
by beholder (No verified email address) |
Current rating: 0 16 Apr 2005
|
Who is troll, regular reader? The person who published this article or someone else. There is the International proverb with the meaning that it is much easier in general to love the entire world than to love your own neighbor. This sentiment is, unfortunately, real in ANY part of the world, including this community.
Professional psychiatrists should be sued foe wrongful death in the case of their clients suicides (or for malpractice) the same way as doctors who failed in time to notice his/her patient’s cancer tumor, and subsequently killed their patients. It is exactly the same type of professional malpractice. So, these psychiatric specialists who are organizing this kind of "bureacratical football" with their patients, which the author of this article is describing, should simply lose their professional licenses if their patients would really commit suicide, as the result.
So, comment of uh-nawn is not only rude and shows no compation at all to the person who needs the professional treatment, but simply stupid, as he/she obviously didn't understand what he/she was talking about. |
Re: Psychiatric Abuse of a Client at the Mental Health Center of Champaign County |
by beholder (No verified email address) |
Current rating: 0 16 Apr 2005
|
Sorry, I've read again my own comment. As it was dark and late when I placed it, I used 'foe' instead of 'for' and 'compation' instead of 'compassion'.
And, regular reader, I am not trying to discredit IMC activities, just trying to prevent such rude and fully illiterate reaction, which uh-nawn has exhibited here. |
|