|
Parent Article: Norman Finkelstein to speak at Law School Tuesday evening |
|
Hidden with code "Duplicate post" |
|
Relevance of Finklestein's Parents |
by Paul Kotheimer
herringb (nospam) prairienet.org (unverified) |
Current rating: 0
08 Mar 2005
|
It seems like the idea in mentioning Finklestein's parents in his bio is to increase Finklestein's "rhetorical unassailability."
The argument runs something like this:
"You can't possibly accuse somebody both of whose parents are Jewish Holocaust survivors of 'Anti-Semitism'!...Or, you could, but most people wouldn't buy it. So, when such a person argues against the current state of affairs in Israel/Palestine, the fact of their parentage makes it harder to just blow off what they say."
Does such an argument make logical sense? Maybe it does and maybe it doesn't. But I personally would think that an academic with two Jewish Holocaust survivors for parents would tend to care genuinely, and care A LOT, about what it means to be Jewish in the aftermath of World War II. |
