The UC-IMC Steering Committee would like to comment on the recent
controversy surrounding the following claim, made by Sascha Meinrath
at a press conference announcing the purchase of the UCIMC's new
building:
"There are over 150 Independent Media Centers in 50 plus countries
worldwide. And this IMC here in Urbana-Champaign is the umbrella
under which the entire global network operates. We are in essence
the global headquarters for the Indymedia movement, here in
Urbana."
Several UC-IMCistas were offended by this comment, as were others in
the Indymedia network. We believe this statement was worded badly and
needs clarification.
The Indymedia network operates on principles of autonomy and
non-hierarchy, and the UC-IMC strongly affirms these principles. The
UC-IMC, a 501(c)3 non-profit organization, hosts the funds of a number
of other projects, including some other Indymedia collectives. This
is a service we provide only at the request of these other
organizations.
There are two ways to look at the structure of the IMC network: the
organizational structure and the legal/fiscal structure. So much of
the workings of the IMC network on a day-to-day basis are related to
the organizational structure that IMCistas sometimes are surprised to
learn that there is a legal/fiscal structure too.
This legal/fiscal structure was created by consensus of the IMC
network in 2001 and 2002. There is a global Finance working group
operating through the imc-finance mailing list. In 2002, this working
group consensed that for legal purposes -- that is, on paper -- the
Global Indymedia network is "fiscally sponsored" by the UC-IMC. This
means that, under US tax law, UC-IMC has legally shared its status as
a non-profit organization with the Global Indymedia network.
Additional details describing and documenting this relationship and
the rationale behind it are available on the UC-IMC website.
There is nothing permanent about this fiscal sponsorship, nor should
there be. UC-IMC actively encourages working toward other solutions
-- either that other US IMC collectives gain 501(c)3 status
independent of UC-IMC and allow the fiscal sponsorship of Global to
rotate among them; or that Global Indymedia Network become a 501(c)3
itself.
Without this fiscal context, however -- a context many IMCistas were
not likely to know about, and which Sascha didn't provide in his
off-the-cuff statement -- the comment "this IMC here in
Urbana-Champaign is the umbrella under which the entire global network
operates" sounds like a direct attack on organizational autonomy
between Indymedia collectives, rather than a statement about the
legal/fiscal organization of the Indymedia network.
We at UC-IMC strongly affirm the principle of the autonomy of the IMC
collectives, and regret that a statement was made by a member of our
collective apparently undermining that principle. We recognize that
there were IMCistas deeply offended by the implications of the
statement, and we apologize for inadvertently appearing, through
miscommunication, to suggest that we do not recognize and honor the
principle of organizational autonomy between IMC collectives.
We also wish to affirm that the above statement by Sascha was
accurately reported by our radio volunteer, Dave Berliner. The
reporting of that statement and the implications contained within it
was not a mistake on the part of the IMCista.
Note: This is the official statement consensed to by the UC IMC Steering Group on June 16th, 2005. Further information about this issue may be found in the first comment below.
|